Alan Tregoning - Screenwriter
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Awards
  • Produced Work
    • Short FIlms >
      • Riva (2015)
      • Dig (2015)
      • Harper Abbott (2014)
      • Possessed (2013)
      • Static (2012)
      • The Code (2011)
      • Second Glances (2011)
      • Clip (2011)
      • Delivered (2011)
      • Sanctuary (2010)
      • Adoptation (2010)
      • The Dead House Guest (2010)
      • Metal Sandwich (2009)
      • Ronnie's Restaurant (2009)
    • Kid's Shows >
      • iShine Knect
      • Wright's Direction
      • Living With Fish
      • The Book of Destiny
      • The Big Picture
  • Contact Me

Christian Movies and Pink slime

4/4/2012

10 Comments

 
This past month I was reading about the backlash over a filler found in most ground beef called "lean finely textured beef" or "pink slime".  The stuff is basically made from the electronically separated bits of the cow carcass that are treated with ammonium gas to kill the germs.  What is left is technically ground beef, but is not the most appetizing.  If you don't believe me then take a look here

While I was driving home from work yesterday it suddenly occurred to me that Christian movies are just like pink slime.

1 - They both have been sanitized.   I'm not sure where it happens in the film making process, but it seems that at some point every Christian film is washed in that cloud of ammonium gas.  The result is something clean, sanitized and safe for the whole family to eat.

2 - They both don't look very appetizing - So you're at the multiplex on a Friday night with $10 burning in your pocket.  Quick what do you go see? Fireproof or Eagle Eye? Courageous or Moneyball?  October Baby or The Hunger Games?  Hollywood knows how to sell the sizzle on their steak.

3 - They both suffer from bad public perception.  "It's 100% beef" cry the pink slime manufacturers.  Sure, but it looks gross.  "It's a great movie for the entire family" yeah it may be 100% movie but that doesn't mean I want to consume it.

Great restaurants normally boil down to one thing, how good is the food.  Serve up a big plate of pink slime enough times and your are out of business.  The same way people don't go to a restaurant to eat an inferior meal, people don't want to go to the movies to watch an inferior film.  People want to be entertained, to get lost in a story and its characters. 

The best way to reach people with your film is to make it with excellence and integrity.  Quality does still matter, and all that starts with a great story and not with a big steaming bowl of pink slime. 

10 Comments
Ralph
4/4/2012 08:12:33 am

great comparison -thanks!

Reply
Brett link
4/4/2012 08:16:31 am

A-friggin'-men!

Reply
Bobby
4/4/2012 08:20:59 am

In a nutshell!

Reply
Dawn Nicole Baldwin link
4/4/2012 08:52:22 am

Well said.

(On my feet.. standing ovation)

Reply
Kelly
4/5/2012 07:55:37 am

No disrespect but I feel this is a broad generalization and perhaps fails to take into consideration a christian film maker's level of personal comfort zone\conviction...I have watched many Christian films that drew me into the story. As a parent, I welcome ' family friendly' stories with teachable subjects without having to explain things on too mature a level. if a person loves making films but feels they must honor God with the content, I feel it isn't exactly Christian love to liken that to something unappetizing or unhealthy. If a person makes Christian film as their fulfillment to share the Gospel, I see harsh criticism akin to skipping over the heart of a man's sermon to list the# of times he said "Um" I agree that quality is important and think reality should make it obvious that most filmmakers with a message are utilizing substantially smaller budgets than major studios... This argument rings to me like the old hymns vs contemporary music debate...boils down to prefrence and not necessarily content...I am in no easy a christian film maker, dint know any and watch movies made by all the mainstream folks as well as lots of indie, sundance type stuff...i just dint think it is a balanced consideration of what Christian film us meant to be...less like pink slime in my book, more like the organic health section in Kroger-for a select few who prefer soy to dairy ;) Happy Easter! He is risen from the dead, and He is Lord!
~k

Reply
Alan Tregoning
4/6/2012 06:49:12 am

Hi Kelly, Thanks for taking the time to respond to my blog post. I appreciate your thoughts. I like your comparison to the organic health section of the grocery store. Well said. I do agree that I did make a broad generalization but that is because when is comes to Christian movies there is a broad perception that they are not going to be good. There are certainly some bright spots out there, I really enjoyed the movie "Luther" and "Amazing Grace" was pretty good too, but in general Christian film suffers from a poor reputation due to its inferior product. I don't think that low budgets are to blame, I have seen plenty of low budget films by mainstream filmmakers that are wonderful and I have seen larger budget films by Christian filmmakers that stink.

I believe that God does call people to make movies for his glory, but what does it say about the filmmaker when they respond to that calling by making a poor film? God didn't call Noah to build a leaky boat after all. Perhaps you a right in that it does come down to personal preference. Most Christian films tend to be "call to action" type films where they seek to shine the light on a particular problem or issue and then lay out a plan of action to over come said problem or issue. The problem I see with that approach is that it doesn't address the reason why most people go to the movies. People don't go to the movies to watch a three part sermon or to join a cause. People go to the movies to be entertained, to enjoy a good story and engaging characters. So as Christians when we learn to write better stories we'll make better movies.

Reply
Kelly
4/7/2012 10:55:30 am

:) Thanks for the reply. I definitely understand where you're coming from and agree with the ideas behind it. I love a really good film...any type really. If it is good, it should transcend genre to a degree (like music, books, coffee...) if you're a believer, and I admit I'm not aware if you claim to be- you just came across my twitter feed... I believe we are called to build each other up with our words and ideas... If there is a call for change or better product, challenge can be issued in a way that may inspire filmmakers in positive ways...more flies with honey, as they say :)
Have a very blessed Easter! He is risen!
~k

Kelly
4/7/2012 10:55:42 am

:) Thanks for the reply. I definitely understand where you're coming from and agree with the ideas behind it. I love a really good film...any type really. If it is good, it should transcend genre to a degree (like music, books, coffee...) if you're a believer, and I admit I'm not aware if you claim to be- you just came across my twitter feed... I believe we are called to build each other up with our words and ideas... If there is a call for change or better product, challenge can be issued in a way that may inspire filmmakers in positive ways...more flies with honey, as they say :)
Have a very blessed Easter! He is risen!
~k

robyn blaikie collins link
4/5/2012 01:34:03 pm

while i'm about to vomit from the grossness... i think you make some really good points.

seriously nauseous... which means that was some good writing.
ick.

Reply
Cholo link
5/2/2012 02:11:10 pm

Nice post.Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful! I've been looking for books of this nature for a way too long. I'm just glad that I found yours. Looking forward for your next post. Thanks :)

Cholo
www.0y7.net

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    welcome

    I am a screenwriter and a story teller. Jesus related to the culture of the day through simple stories that illustrated God's kingdom principles. My passion is to follow his example.

    Archives

    December 2016
    June 2015
    June 2013
    February 2013
    July 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Awards
  • Produced Work
    • Short FIlms >
      • Riva (2015)
      • Dig (2015)
      • Harper Abbott (2014)
      • Possessed (2013)
      • Static (2012)
      • The Code (2011)
      • Second Glances (2011)
      • Clip (2011)
      • Delivered (2011)
      • Sanctuary (2010)
      • Adoptation (2010)
      • The Dead House Guest (2010)
      • Metal Sandwich (2009)
      • Ronnie's Restaurant (2009)
    • Kid's Shows >
      • iShine Knect
      • Wright's Direction
      • Living With Fish
      • The Book of Destiny
      • The Big Picture
  • Contact Me